There is a dog trainer on every corner, each with their own methods, and it can feel impossible to know who is right. After more than a decade of training, here is the cold hard truth: the best method is the one you will actually use, every day, for the life of your dog.
It is not the trainer’s job to train your dog
That sounds strange coming from a trainer, so let me explain. You are not really paying me to train your dog. You are paying me to hand you my knowledge and skillset. Most of us teach the same way: explain the skill, demonstrate it with your dog, then coach you while you practice. I have your dog for about an hour a week. You have them the other seven days. Your practice between sessions is the only thing that makes training stick.
So when someone tells me “I did training and it did not work,” the honest answer is usually that the dog was trained, but the practice stopped. And “my dog listens to you, not me” is no mystery either: trainers get results because we are fluent, and fluency comes from practice, the very thing we are asking of your dog.
Stop over-talking your dog
Dogs communicate through body language and a handful of sounds, and we tend to drown them in words. The most common mistake I see sounds like this: “Fido, Fido, can you sit for mommy? Sit, sit, sit, no, I need you to sit…” The dog, overwhelmed, finally offers a paw out of confusion, gets a treat, and learns the wrong thing. A few problems are hiding in there:
- The frantic, repeated name tells your dog something is wrong.
- Saying “sit, sit, sit” teaches that the cue is “sit, sit, sit,” not “sit.”
- Rewarding the paw cancels out the sit.
Keep cues short, clear, calm, and confident, and follow through. If you ask for a sit and your dog slides into a down, help them back up into the sit before rewarding. One clear word, said once, beats a paragraph every time.
Dogs do not generalize
Your dog’s “sit” in a quiet kitchen is not the same as “sit” on a walk while a stranger coos at them. That is not stubbornness; it is simply how dogs learn. Help them in new places by showing the reward or luring if needed, and expect every dog to progress at their own pace. It is our job to teach them what we expect, because they can only learn what we teach and reinforce.
None of this requires harsh tools, just consistency and clear communication. If you want a coach who will teach you as much as your dog, that is exactly what private in-home lessons are for, and it is also why I am honest about the limits of board and train.